Saturday, February 1, 2014

Change Can Happen


Before I get into the text, I want to say how much I enjoyed reading Jonathan Kozol’s “Amazing Grace”.  This text was extremely eye opening and almost unbelievable.  I cannot even imagine living in the circumstances he writes about at any age at any point in my life.  But, the sad part is, you never know if you could end up in this predicament. 

Kozol writes on living life in Mott Haven.  Mott Haven is known as the poorest and most racially segregated town in our nation.  It consists of drug dealers, prostitution, crimes, and innocent people trying to survive on a daily basis. 

In this poor town is a church on St. Ann’s Avenue called St. Ann’s Church.  It is said that the men, women, and children who come to this church are the “poorest of the poor” but, “In one of the most diseased and dangerous communities in any city of the Western world, the beautiful old stone church on St. Ann’s Avenue is a gentle sanctuary from the terrors of the streets outside”(6).  Even with the lives that these individuals live, they are still praying and looking for hope to brighten their day, week, year, or life.  And, as Kozol speaks with a few people who attend the church he is able to see this exactly.  Whether it is Cliffie, the seven-year-old boy who sees the bad but looks for the good, or his mother who is proud of how her son is living his life despite their circumstance.  This one instance speaks for the many individuals who try to escape the outside world of their dangerous and scary lives by coming to the one calm place they know and treasure.

Although Kozol saw Cliffie’s life while inside the calm church he then also sees it while out in the dangerous neighborhood he calls his home.  Kozol has Cliffie show him around and asks him questions on the way.  One instance that really opened my eyes was when they were walking by a vacant lot.  In this lot were old parts along with needles and crack containers.  As Cliffie points to these objects that not every seven-year-old would recognize he says, “The day is coming when the world will be destroyed. Everyone is going to be burned to crispy cookies” (10).  This honestly broke my heart.  First off that he even knows what needles and crack containers are is devastating.  Cliffie understands that these objects are bad and that they are ruining not only others life but his as well.  This young boy is having to grow up way too quickly and should not need to encounter these types of incidents. 

Along with Cliffie and the other members of the church, Kozol also talked to Alice Washington and her son.  Them too felt unsafe in their own home, and overall in their lives.  Mrs. Washington was sick and had much difficulty with the hospital.  She felt unsafe in the hospital that usually is considered a “safe place” and also in her own house.  While staying home and hoping to get better she struggles with the heat and staying alive, “You know it’s dangerous to do it but you got to go outside. You either go outside and take your chance or else you roast inside the house” (19).  Since it was summertime, the heat and humidity built up and made it difficult to breath within her home and with her illness.  But, she was afraid to even open her window to get some fresh air.  Mrs. Washington again explains the difficulty of living life in Mott Haven.  Basically, while trying to stay alive, she is risking her life. 

Overall, through “Amazing Grace” by Kozol I received a new perspective on how some people struggle everyday to stay alive.  From such a young age to such an old age these individuals are struggling no matter how hard they try or what their lives may have been like before.  And the upper class people are not helping at all.  Whether they pay no attention, dump their trash in the poor towns, or send whatever they do not want to the poorer sections of town, it is only making life worse for these innocent individuals.  


Above is a picture of a Mott Haven backyard when this article was written in 1995.  I feel as if this may just sum up the living conditions in this part of town.  

This news article from the New York Times was written sixteen years after "Amazing Grace".  I found it very interesting to read on how Mott Haven is doing nowadays.  From this article the changes are seen.  Although it is still considered a little challenged it is filled with potential and seems better than before.  It consists of new residents who are only looking to make their new home better than ever.

Below are some more recent pictures of Mott Haven.  From these, you would never expect the stories from "Amazing Grace" to have occurred here.  But, they did.  Imagine what these exact spots may have looked like sixteen years ago!!!

CHANGE CAN HAPPEN!

11 comments:

  1. Hey! I couldn't agree more with everything you have written! These people struggle no matter why age and pray to live another day in the city they live in. When Cliffie was explaining the different parts of where he lives and commenting of what happens where it was sad. A child so young to have seen so much or whiteness everything that has happened at such a young age; heartbreaking. Your pictures were great as well! I wouldn't have expected what happened al those years ago to have happened in the pics you posted either.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hey! I completely agree with everything you stated in your post as well as with what Jacklyn commented. When I first read the article, it made me feel mad and angry, but most importantly it made feel indignation. I couldn’t believe what those children, and families, and basically everyone had to face. It was not fair, and as you stated in your post, I can’t even imagine living like the people in Mott Haven. Yet, I when I saw post, and I saw those pictures that show improvement and the hope for a better life for the residents of Mott Haven, I felt better. I am so glad that now change is happening and that the people living there can experience a better life and certainly better opportunities and living conditions.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I really liked what you wrote here and I couldn't agree more! The life of the children growing up during that time was really bad and there was really nothing that they could have done. The fact that most of those families were living on the street, living in fear of their lives everyday just gave me the chills when I was reading it. I really liked the pictures you posted as well and also the tranformation. You're right, change can happen but it does take time!! I also really liked this article and it was very eye opening to see how lucky some of us really are.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hey! I really like your positive spin on the situation presented in the text. I like that you took the time to find photos to show what Mott Haven looks like now in comparison to how it looked before. I also liked that you found a photo of Mott Haven back in 1995 to show that it was really bad and you didn't just show us how great it all looks now. You did a great job at giving us both photos and we can really see as you said "change can happen". Great Job. I couldn't agree with you more.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I agree with these posts as well, I love how you included those pictures at the end. When I originally started reading the article I feel upset, and I wished there was something I could have done to help their situation. So the improvements that these pictures show are very encouraging, and give hope for a better life in Mott Haven and especially for the children. I find it so troubling for an innocent child to have to face so many tragedies at that young of an age.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hey Viv here, Did anyone else cry? I thought our first reading, "Privilege, Power and difference" was jolting. I have intentionally avoided watching the news because I find it too depressing. This article was depressing, but also spoke of human resilience. You did a great job comparing Mott Haven in 1995 with photos of how it appears today. And you are right, Change can happen. And no I am not a robot.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Hey i loved the way you set this up ! I mean reading your recap of all the negative aspects in Mott Haven was sad. And I completely agree with the points you made about it. And the photo of Mott Haven in 1995 was pretty heart breaking. But honestly recapping all those sad moments was totally worth it to see those bright positive pictures of Mott Haven at the end of your post was so worth it. I loved that you took the time to look those up. It was a great read !

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hey ! I love how you took this depressing account and put a positive spin on it. Many tend to dwell on the negative without realizing that they are capable of changing anything, so long as they make an effort. From the pictures you found of then and now in Mott Haven, it is clear that the residents are surely trying to turn things around. Nice work !

    ReplyDelete
  9. Hey Madison, I really think you did a great job explaining this piece! You literally took the words out of my mouth. My favorite part was when you mentioned Cliffie and said, "the seven-year-old boy who sees the bad but looks for the good". That's a great way to describe him and I never thought of it like that. I cannot believe how mature this little boy is at such a young age. This story breaks my heart to see how terrible living conditions were in Mott Haven in 1995. Lastly, I just wanted to say that you did such an amazing thing at the end! I liked how you showed before and after pictures. I hope Mott Haven is a lot better than it was eighteen years ago when Kozol wrote this piece!

    ReplyDelete
  10. Hey Madison!! You did an awesome job explaining his piece! I totally agree with your points! Imagine this was only 18 years ago! Imagine if we were just being born in Mott Haven... I wonder what the 18 year olds who live their feel about the history of their city. Thanks for putting up those pictures! You allowed us to see what Mott Haven really looks like! Good job with your post! :)

    ReplyDelete
  11. I really love the direction you took with this post. While the article itself has a lot of negative thoughts and helplessness attached to it, and you explained them well, you managed to turn it into a positive view by noticing the positive change that can happen in society. That change is just as, if not more, eye-opening than the article itself. Fantastic job!

    ReplyDelete